It was a bad time to be God’s prophet.
Jeremiah first prophesied under King Josiah of Judah, who shared Jeremiah’s opposition to idolatry. Josiah cleared the idols out of the temple and tried to wipe out the worship of other gods in Judah.1 But when the Egyptian army marched toward Assyria, Pharaoh Nekho II led his troops through the western edge of Judah. King Josiah attacked them at Megiddo, and was killed in battle.
The pharaoh appointed Josiah’s son Jehoiakim as the next king of Judah, and Jehoiakim began his 11-year reign as an obedient vassal of Egypt, sending regular tributes of silver and gold. Then in 605 BCE the new Babylonian empire won a major battle against the Egyptians at Carchemish, in the heart of the former Assyrian empire. King Jehoiakim switched his allegiance.
In his days, Nebuchadnezar, king of Babylon, came up, and Jehoiakim was his vassal for three years. Then he turned and rebelled against him. (2 Kings 24:1)
Rebelling against King Nebuchadnezar II was a big mistake. The Babylonian army conquered all of Judah except its capital, then laid siege to the walled city of Jerusalem in 599 BCE.
Jeremiah prophesied that God was not on Judah’s side any more, thanks to the bad behavior of its people, and therefore the king should surrender and send tribute to Babylon once more. King Jehoiakim was not amused. While Jerusalem was under siege, the king imprisoned Jeremiah and tried to assassinate him.
Two passages from Jeremiah compose the haftarah (the reading from the Prophets) accompanying this week’s Torah portion (Tzav in the book of Leviticus). In the first passage, Jeremiah 7:21-8:3, God warns the prophet about the worst that can happen if people do not obey God. The second passage, Jeremiah 9:22-23, ends this week’s reading on a happier note.
The worst
The haftarah begins with God complaining that the Israelites are still making the standard offerings (the ones required in the Torah portion Tzav), as if that were all they needed to do to please God.
Thus said the God of Armies, God of Israel: “Add your olot to your[other] slaughter-offerings and eat the meat! For I did not speak to your fathers and I did not command them at the time I brought them out from the land of Egypt about matters of olah and slaughter. For with this word I commanded them, saying: Heed my voice, and I will be your God and you will be my people. Walk on every path that I command you, so that it will go well for you.” (Jeremiah 7:21-23)
olah (עוֹלָה) = rising offering; an offering in which a slaughtered animal is completely burned up into smoke that rises up to the heavens. (Plural olot, עֺלוֹת.)
Ever since the exodus from Egypt, God continues, the people have refused to listen and obey—even though God keeps sending prophets who repeat the message. Then God tells Jeremiah:
“And you will speak all these words to them, but they will not listen to you. And you will call to them, but they will not respond.” (Jeremiah 7:27)
Instead, God predicts, they will continue to set up idols in God’s temple, and they will continue to burn their own children at the shrine of Tofet in the Valley of Ben-hinom, just south of the temple mount in Jerusalem.
“Therefore, hey! The days are coming,” declares God, “when no one will say ‘the Tofet’ or ‘the Valley of Hinom’ any more, but rather ‘the Valley of the Mass Killing’. And they will bury at Tofet until there is no space left.” (Jeremiah 7:32)
Then, God says, it will get even worse. Since there will be too many corpses to bury, the bodies will be desecrated by wild animals. Furthermore, the people’s beloved land, already trampled by the Babylonian army, will become a wasteland.
“And the corpses of these people will be food for the birds of the sky and the beasts of the land, and there will be no one frightening them off. And I will make the sound of gladness and of rejoicing cease in the towns of Judah and the streets of Jerusalem, the voice of the bridegroom and the voice of the bride. For the land will become a desolation.” (Jeremiah 7:33-34)
Yet even this is not enough. God is so fed up with the people of Judah that the dead will not be allowed to rest in peace.
“At that time,” declares God, “they will bring from out of their graves the bones of the kings of Judah, the bones of its officers, the bones of it priests, the bones of its prophets, and the bones of the inhabitants of Jerusalem. And they will be spread out under the sun and the moon … They will not be gathered and not reburied; they will become manure on the face of the earth.” (Jeremiah 8:1-2)
The earlier graves would be located outside the city, like the Valley of Hinom. Who would bother to ransack them? The 11th-century commentator Rashi suggested the Babylonian invaders, called “Chaldeans” at the time.
“And the Chaldeans shall dwell, when they besiege the city, in the graves of the princes, that were as beautiful as palaces.” (Rashi)2
Or perhaps the invading army would desecrate graveyards in order to humiliate the Jerusalemites and move them to despair.
“Exposure of the dead was considered a great dishonor and desecration throughout the ancient world.” (Etz Chayim)3
The horrifying prophecy concludes:
“And death will be more desirable than life for all the remaining remainders of this wicked clan, in all the remaining places where I will drive them,” declares the God of Armies. (Jeremiah 8:3)
Vindictive or kind?
This passage and many others in the book of Jeremiah make God sound like a vindictive ruler with an anger management problem. The message could be summarized: If any of you disobey me, you’ll all wish you’d never been born!
On the other hand, the God of Jeremiah asks the Judahites not only to refrain from worshiping other gods, but also to behave decently to one another. Before the haftarah reading, Jeremiah reports that what God wants the most is for people to eschew injustice; oppression of strangers, orphans, and widows; and shedding the blood of the innocent.4
After the first passage in this week’s reading, God continues to rant about how wicked the people are and how devastating their punishment will be. But the rabbis who chose the haftarot over the centuries tried to end on a hopeful note. In the case of Haftarat Tzav, they appended a two-verse poem, the next positive passage in Jeremiah:
Thus said God:
Let not the wise one boast about his wisdom,
And let not the strong one boast about his strength.
Let not the rich one boast about his riches.
For only of this may a boaster boast:
Of insight and acquaintance with me.
For I am God, doing kindness,
Justice, and righteousness on earth.
For in these I delight,
Declares God. (Jeremiah 9:22-23)
Communal versus individual justice
If God is kind and just, why does God let the Babylonian army kill so many people, including orphans, widows, and the innocent?
Throughout the Hebrew Bible, God treats people collectively. If enough of the population is at fault, God punishes everyone.
In the book of Jeremiah, the punishment is not the worst-case scenario of the first passage in this week’s haftarah. Later the book describes how the Babylonian army breaches the walls of Jerusalem and burns down the city and its temple. The people who have surrendered are put in fetters and marched off to exile in Babylon. A Babylonian official who knows about Jeremiah’s prophecies lets the prophet himself go free, and Jeremiah spends his final years with a group of Judahite refugees in Egypt.
Even if the outcome is not the worst that can happen, it is still personally devastating for a lot of innocent people. Why does God punish everyone in the community for the crimes of only some of its population?
Collective punishment is not perfect justice. If we think of God as a person who controls our fates, then we must protest, like Abraham:
“Far be it from you to do this thing, to bring death to the innocent along with the wicked, so the innocent and the wicked will fare alike! Far be it from you, the judge of all the earth, to not do justice!” (Genesis 18:25)
But collective punishment is a reality. When enough humans pollute the air, we all suffer from global climate change. When enough humans are inflamed by a demagogue, we all live in fear of terrorism and the seizure of the government. And when humans in power decide to make war, innocent people die.
- 2 Kings 22:3-23:16.
- Rashi (Rabbi Shlomoh Yitzchaki), translated in www.sefaria.org.
- Commentary edited by Chaim Potok, Etz Hayim, Rabbinical Assembly of the United Synagogue of Conservative Judaism, 2001, p. 628.
- Jeremiah 7:5-6.